Thought Provoking Thursday – The Bible, Fact or Fiction?

OK, Thursdays is for provoking thought!  In other words, I might say some things that you find controversial or at least a make you think!  Hopefully, today’s title is a good start!

First of all, let me be really clear.  I am a follower of Jesus Christ because that is how I encountered God.  The bible has been truly inspirational in my quest for knowledge and as a guide to living a better life and creating a more meaningful story.  My question is;  just how do we view this famous piece of literature and why are their so many different interpretations as to what it purports to say?  Was the universe created in a literal six days simply by God speaking it into being?  Is the writer of Ecclesiastes’ invitation to ‘Eat drink and be merry for tomorrow we die’ an exhortation to guide us in our daily living?  Why do we not insist on women being silent in church, or demand they wear head covering in all public gatherings?  And why do some believe that the locusts of Revelation 9 are really Apache attack helicopters described the best way John knew how?  Why does it matter?

First of all, a slice of history.  In the 16th century, a rather seismic event took place in christendom known as ‘The Reformation’.  You may recall Martin Luther and the advent of Protestantism emerging as a reaction to the state of disarray that existed in the Catholic Church at the time with warring popes, indulgences and theological schisms.  One of the key outcomes of this movement was a transference from papal based to bible based authority.  This is also what led to the bible being made available to the masses and a whole new church movement.  The protestant movement also gave rise to denominational splits as never seen before as the ‘authority’ of the bible was interpreted in hundreds if not thousands of different ways.  And herein lies the problem.

The bible is, in fact, not so much a book as a library of books.  These books cover many genres of literature, styles of writing, languages and purposes.  There is the poetry of the creation account, the visions of Revelation often referencing the prophetic writings of the Old Testament.  There are the songs of Psalms and the wisdom of Proverbs, the stories of Jesus and the doctrinal teachings of Paul.  Diverse cultures, races and very different ages influence the way in which these writings are presented and all of them need re-evaluating against what we now know in this scientific age.

Let us take the creation account.  At the time of writing, there was no knowledge of evolutionary theory, relativity, quantum theory and hey, as far as they knew, the earth was flat and the sun popped up in the East and went to sleep in the west.  I have no problem personally with the idea that science is merely man’s quest to uncover the mysteries behind the creation of the universe, nor do I struggle with the contemporary writer’s poetic depiction, but I believe it is beyond me to give you any idea of what actually happened back then when none of us were around.  I’m also OK if God made a big bang when he did it, but frankly it doesn’t matter to me.  One thing is for certain, the world as we know it today is very real and very wonderful to behold.

In many of the books of law in the Old testament there are injunctions to put to death those who sow different crops in the same field or create garments from different materials.  Surely we are not meant to continue these practices in civilized 21st century society.  When we move on to accounts of the life of Jesus himself we find that much of what Jesus says is fiction.  What you say, heresy!  But step back a minute.  Jesus told stories, parables…fiction to illustrate truth.  And this is where I think we have strayed from the intention of this marvelous collection of writings.

In many ways, we have treated as fact what is meant to lead us to truth.  Because this library is full of metaphor, parable, allegory, poetry, prophecy, vision, law and history, this is not a book of facts but an inspired guide to uncovering truth.  This truth, in some ways, will never be completely found, as God cannot be confined to the pages of a library of books.  This truth can be seen from multiple different perspectives and often in conflicting expressions.  My mistake so often has been to imagine that my  interpretation of selective portions proves that my way is ‘the right way’.  One of the most powerful causes of my own disillusionment with church has been our tendency to become more and more splintered around issues that are not central to the overall message of the Bible.  Perhaps we can all agree that the inspired message of this library of scripture is that God loves us and wants to have a relationship with us.  Every one of us is entitled to a unique experience just as in any relationship.  We would do well not to dictate to others what that relationship should look like but allow the inspired words we read to change our own story for the good of the world around us.

In conclusion, and answer to my own question, the Bible is neither fact nor fiction, but an inspired reference library for the pursuit of the God of love.

8 thoughts on “Thought Provoking Thursday – The Bible, Fact or Fiction?

  1. My thoughts exactly. I too have become disillusioned with “Church” or “Churches” and feel the same way. I also feel that this view doesn’t fit very well with people that religiously attend churches, here in New Zealand anyway.


    • Thanks Paul. I still feel the church is an important part of the picture and I am still hopeful that more people are ready to explore a less narrow course – keep the faith and glad you are part of the conversation


  2. I think the question of whether the Bible is fact or fiction is too broad and abstract to be all that meaningful, and so dodging that question as you did in favor of more interesting questions is something I support. But there are some specific factual propositions that aren’t so trivial: for example, Jesus either raised from the dead or he didn’t. That has to be fact or fiction and a lot depends on it. I’m curious how important a specific question like that is to you.

    Also, nice job finding a title for the website!


    • Thanks Josiah – good point on the title – I was going for eye catching rather than substantive. As with a lot of this stuff – I find the typical blog length too short to say too much but I will need to develop many of the issues on subsequent occasions. As for the resurrection, I do believe the historical account. As with all history, we rely on those who were there at the time and at least in this case, have more than one account of this event and subsequent appearances of someone they were convinced was the risen Jesus.


  3. Let’s go one step further. If the bible is a library, surely it’s just one of a large number of libraries. Truth, if such a thing can be known, is surely revealed in writings, pictures, music and the natural world and is continually being both revealed and reappraised.

    And Josiah does go to the heart of the matter. Some factual claims are clearly true or not. Given that most are unprovable one way or the other it seems to me that none of us should attempt to claim truth over anyone else. I’m afraid we live in ignorance.


    • Mark thanks for that and yes that’s a great place for all of us to acknowledge. ‘Claiming truth over anyone else’ is at the heart of so much strife and discord. If only the ‘truth’ we find for ourselves had its biggest impact in changing our own lives for the better, which was the essence of my conclusion. Also, the vast majority of history can no longer be proved as fact but relies on our faith in the honesty of those who recorded it. Faith has a big part to play in how we view this particular library of books


  4. I accept your question and support the answer you come up with. 🙂

    A song sung by many of us when growing up in Sunday School went along the lines of: “Every promise in the Book is mine, every chapter, every verse, every line.” I do not accept the “theology” of that song. Many of the instructions aimed at the people of Israel included promises of retribution and other bad results from disobedience. Death was promised for a variety of what we might consider inconsequential in our churches today. For instance: To be found working on the Sabbath could result in death. How many of us “good” Christians work on Saturday (the seventh day), or on Sunday, if that is the preferred sabbath?

    The Old Testament is to me a story of God’s dealing with a particular people … a tribe chosen by God through which the Messiah, the Redeemer, was to come into the world. The New Testament gives us the story of Jesus and of the building of the early Church.

    As to my position: I have made the CHOICE to believe what is written in II Timothy 3:16: “All Scripture is God-breathed and is good for …. so that the man of God may be thouroughly equipped for every good work.” I also choose to accept the 66 books of the Bible as the Scripture to which the Apostle Paul refers. In this collection of books I find guidance on how I should live by examining the examples of those who have gone before. Yes, there are some very specific instructions that apply to us today: “Thou shalt love the Lord they God with all thy might …. and they neighbour as thyself”. Every doctrine or Christian creed that I wish to support should fit within that instruction.

    I would love to continue on; however, Jan is waiting for me to take her to Kerikeri to visit her sister Margie and husband Ken. (They were with us in the RV last summer when we came through Texas.)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s